In fact, there’s loads extra nuance to the controversy than that. As an illustration, some consider that whereas a straight actor enjoying a homosexual or bisexual character is appropriate, portraying trans individuals ought to at all times be left to members of that group. Others say that the entire level of performing is to embody a perspective apart from your personal, and due to this fact it would not make sense to contemplate sexuality or gender id in casting. Then there’s the truth that the inequity of opportunity and representation within the leisure trade signifies that straight or cisgender actors accepting LGBTQ+ roles may very well be inadvertently inflicting their friends to lose work, in addition to the truth that whereas celebrities could also be public figures, we as viewers members haven’t got entry to their personal lives, and assuming that they are straight or cis could be damaging in and of itself.
In a 2020 interview with Variety, Kristen Stewart stated about this problem, “I might by no means need to inform a narrative that basically ought to be advised by anyone who’s lived that have. Having stated that, it’s a slippery slope dialog as a result of which means I may by no means play one other straight character if I’m going to carry everybody to the letter of this explicit legislation.”
She added that it’s “such a grey space,” and that listening to the responses of the group you are attempting to characterize is of paramount significance. She defined, “I imply, in the event you’re telling a narrative a few group they usually’re not welcoming to you, then fuck off. But when they’re, and also you’re turning into an ally and part of it and there’s one thing that drove you there within the first place that makes you uniquely endowed with a perspective that is perhaps worthwhile, there’s nothing mistaken with studying about one another.”
Stewart concluded, “So my reply is fucking take into consideration what you’re doing! And don’t be an asshole.” Phrases to stay by, actually.