Kevin helps his spouse’s grandmother substitute her outdated Saturn. The household is searching for a automotive fitted to an older driver, one thing that’s dependable but additionally actually easy. No screens or expertise that an 80-year-old driver would discover irritating. With a $15,000 finances, what automotive ought to they purchase?
(Welcome again to What Car Should You Buy? The place we give actual folks actual recommendation about shopping for vehicles. Would you like us that will help you discover a automotive? Submit your story on our form.)
Right here is the situation:
My spouse’s grandmother wants to exchange her 2001 Saturn SL. I don’t suppose she believes it, however her 1 mechanic, 7 youngsters, 32 grandchildren, and seven great-grandchildren all agree that the Saturn ought to now not orbit round city. I’m in search of your assist in discovering an acceptable substitute 4-door sedan that the household can current to her.
The important thing right here is discovering a automotive that’s easy with apparent performance parts. For instance, a pronounced computerized shifter and massive radio buttons – completely no screens!
Whereas this might not be essentially the most energetic of searches, I feel the problem is a noble one among looking for a extra up-to-date automotive with old-school simplicity. We don’t wish to spend greater than $15,000
Price range: as much as $15,000
Location: New England
Each day Driver: Sure
Needs: Easy, dependable, not too huge
Doesn’t need: One thing too tech-heavy
Professional 1: Tom McParland – Soul Easy
Convincing someone who has held onto their car for such a long time that it’s time to upgrade isn’t easy, especially since they are used to the routine of their current ride. The tricky part with this scenario is finding something modern enough to have some life left in the car but not too recent. Like many cases before, where someone is looking for an affordable and practical car, the answer is the Kia Soul. Examples are plentiful, and unlike most Japanese cars that will have much higher miles at this price point, you can score a Kia with well under 100,000 miles on the clock.
The Soul isn’t a traditional sedan body like she is used to but the slightly higher ride height makes ingress/egress a bit easier for older folks. If you target 2015/2016 models you will find a nice big shifter in the middle and easy-to-use HVAC and radio controls. An added benefit to the Soul is the upright body style which provides good sight lines for navigating local traffic. Right here is an instance with slightly below 70,000 for round $14,000.
Professional 2: Andy Kalmowitz – The Smart Alternative
Nobody within the Jalopnik workplaces would ever describe me as an affordable individual, however that’s about to alter. Proper right here is the best choice in your pricey outdated grandma. I ought to know. My grandma is 87 and actually desires to purchase a brand new automotive since her 2004 Chrysler City & Nation is a bit lengthy within the tooth. I’m attempting to get her into one among these myself.
The tenth era Corolla checks each single field your grandma is searching for. It’s the appropriate value. It’s easy. It’s dependable, and it’s not huge in any respect. In actual fact, it’s nearly the identical measurement as her Saturb. Inside there are actually zero screens (apart from the radio and journey odometer shows), and if she’s like my grandma that radio won’t ever be turned on. It’s additionally received about as an enormous a shifter as potential for a compact automotive. In a phrase, it’s excellent.
This particular example is a 2013 mannequin situated in Massachusetts and has underneath 34,000 miles on the clock. For a Toyota, that’s virtually actually model new. As well, it’s received a clear Carfax report and is available in a relatively fairly child blue coloration. What extra may ya ask for? Kevin, my pal, make the appropriate selection. Purchase a Corolla in your grandma. She’ll thanks later.
Professional 3: Adam Ismail – The Greatest Match
These are the sort of WCSYB prompts that basically make you suppose. On the floor, there’s not a lot to it: low-cost, environment friendly, dependable, easy transportation that can carry on chugging for a few years to come back. However the “no screens” ask form of throws a wrench in that, as a result of most vehicles constructed throughout the final decade will fail to adjust to that standards. Additionally, Andy already mentioned Corolla, so what the hell are the remainder of us imagined to do?
Certainly, that’s most likely the only option — however so too could be a Civic or a Match. The Civic received somewhat… angular round this time, with a semi-complicated sprint, and I may see that being somewhat intimidating for an older driver. So here’s a 2012 Fit Sport, computerized transmission, with no reported accidents and 85,000 miles on the odometer. I do know that’s not an insignificant quantity, however these will run ceaselessly. The middle stack controls are all quite simple, and total this instance is fairly clear regardless of its historical past. And, although your spouse’s grandma might not care, this era of Match undoubtedly appeared the perfect. She deserves one thing rad.
Professional 4: José Rodríguez Jr. – Easy, Clear Layouts FTW
Kevin, your spouse’s grandmother’s 20+ yr run along with her Saturn SL is superior. After 20 years in a small sedan, I can see why she’d desire to maintain the identical type issue, however one thing like Tom’s Kia Soul or, say, a Honda Element might be a pleasant improve to the Saturn. The Ingredient has easy-to-read controls and the gear shifter is up on the sprint.
If the scale of this Element shouldn’t be splendid, then possibly this 2009 Toyota Matrix could be a greater match, no pun meant. The Matrix combines the shape issue of the Toyota Corolla and Honda Match talked about above, however, most significantly, it has a easy and clear dashboard with a gear selector inside comfy attain. The A/C controls are three easy dials, and the radio display screen is principally a sliver on the sprint. It’s gloriously easy. Add within the reliability Toyota is understood for, and the Matrix might be it!
The one I linked is pricy, however with underneath 45,000 miles on the odometer, it’s able to go for one more 20 years just like the beloved Saturn. There’s at all times the Pontiac Vibe, too — cousin to the Matrix. Earlier Vibe fashions had Pontiac’s signature blobby buttons, however underneath the rebadge it’s much like the Matrix.